Evidence
Current evidence snapshot for manuscript.md. The manuscript now treats notebook-driven extraction, report continuity, and external-agent notebook authorship as delivered behavior, not as an evaluation plan.
Delivered System
- History-attached Pages via
Page.history_id. - Revision provenance via
PageRevision.edit_source. - Page-scoped chat via
ChatExchange.page_id. - History-aware notebook assistant tools.
- Shared editor, diff, revision, rendering, and API paths for notebooks and standalone reports.
- MCP notebook operations for external-agent authoring, with agent edits recorded as
edit_source="agent"and restores asedit_source="restore".
Vignette Evidence
- Vignette 1: mobile resistome. Four-isolate S. aureus ARG-to-insertion-sequence context analysis. Notebook-referenced on-graph tables and heatmaps extract to a 14-step, 9-output, sample-agnostic workflow that re-runs byte-identical to the validated original.
- Vignette 2: differential ATAC-seq. Corces 2016 hematopoiesis count-matrix analysis contrasting erythroblast and B-cell accessibility. Notebook-referenced PCA, volcano, significant-peak, and ranked top-gained outputs extract to a 13-step, 6-output workflow that reproduces the 45,620 significant-peak result and lineage master-regulator loci.
- Vignette 3: differential ChIP. TAL1 G1E-versus-megakaryocyte binding analysis. A single extraction reproduces the analysis but is condition-pinned; reusable decomposition yields a 5-step map-over peak caller and 29-step pairwise comparator.
Evidence Layers
- Implementation completeness: migrations, API, frontend, assistant tools, revision behavior, MCP operations, and test coverage.
- Worked notebook artifacts: Figures 1-3 show notebooks with on-graph outputs, not pasted figures.
- Workflow handoff: Table 1 and SI Workflows S1-S5 show extracted workflow structure, clean inputs, exposed outputs, and re-run behavior.
- Agent authorship: Figure 4 shows MCP-authored revisions recorded as agent-authored notebook revisions.
Remaining Evidence Gaps
- Exact Galaxy PR number(s), commit range, and release target.
- Current test counts by layer.
- Final venue-specific availability/data-availability handles.
- Optional report-continuity screenshot showing notebook narrative inside an extracted workflow report.